Sunday, 23 August 2015

'Volunteering' at Cambodia Elephant Sanctuary

After an enjoyable few days (more for me than Bro who spent most of the time feeling pretty jip) in Siem Reap, we started our next volunteer project – volunteering for the Cambodia Elephant Sanctuary. This is a new experience altogether as we’ve tried to avoid ‘voluntourism’ projects as our impression of these is that you pay a lot of money for what is ultimately an enjoyable tourist experience, rather than actually being of genuine value, and this on the surface, looked distinctly like it might be one such thing (Borneo is rife with uber-expensive 'volunteer' projects that seem to consist mainly of a spot of token poop-cleaning and a lot of warm-fuzzy orangutan watching, so sorry for being a little sceptical). This project wasn’t too expensive (we couldn’t afford to go if it was), but it still costs more than anything else we’ve done, but in the absence of finding anything more suitable we signed up for a week, on the understanding that we’d stay longer if we thought it was worthwhile.  
So after a week here, what’s our verdict? Hmmm, tricky one. The project itself is awesome. The Cambodian branch in which we are working is actually part of a larger organisation known as Elephant Nature Park. This is based in Chang Mai in Thailand, and has a number of satellite sanctuaries dotted around Thailand, and this one in Cambodia. If you haven’t heard about them this is an organisation who are making incredible waves in the Thai elephant tourism industry which is renowned for the mistreatment of elephants. The ENP are trying to raise awareness and raise standards in elephant working conditions throughout Thailand, by working with local mahouts (elephant handlers), discouraging the use of the bullhook (a nasty device used to control elephants by spiking them in sensitive areas for example the eyes and ears and mouth), working with the Thai Government, and discouraging the ever-popular elephant rides which are a huge industry in Thailand.


Some gorgeous butterflies spotted outside our hut

The ENP (http://elephantnaturepark.org/) have currently rescued approximately 64 elephants from across Thailand, most of whom have been treated extremely badly throughout their lives, and they provide a safe environment for these elephants to see out their days. 

The company is run by its founder, a very impressive Thai woman called Sangduen “Lek” Chailert who is building a worldwide reputation for the incredible work she is doing. After only being here a week, we have heard so many examples of the wonderful work she has been doing to help not just these elephants, but she has also rescued dogs, macaques, geese and a very cute gibbon (more on him later!)! And perhaps just as importantly, she is doing wonderful work with the communities surrounding her sanctuaries. She has wisely realised that for her sanctuaries to be successful she needs the support of the local communities, and recognises the value in their expertise. She seems to care deeply for their welfare, and today we heard how yesterday she paid for one of her worker’s wives to be taken across the border to a hospital in Thailand to be treated for a tumour in her mouth, when the hospital in Siem Reap said they couldn’t help her. She also recently donated mattresses to that same hospital in Siem Reap as she realised how inadequately resourced they were. This woman is a gem.

Lek with a rescued orphaned elephant (thank you internet for this one)

So what’s my gripe with it? Basically my issue with working here is that I think our money is worth a lot more than our time. The ‘work’ we are doing is largely token and much of it is aimed at indulging the tourist and giving them an enjoyable experience with the elephants. In a nutshell, we seem to have signed up for exactly the warm-fuzzy experience that we have been trying to avoid for our whole trip. For example most days we will work for a couple of hours in the morning (granted some of this work has been hard and does feel valuable, but we’re talking 2 hours work in a whole morning!! Bro and I keep trying to find extra things to do but at one point were told (in a friendly manner) “you work too hard” and yesterday we got told we’ve been doing the work of 4 people. Considering we are doing a fraction of the work we did in Borneo, it makes me wonder what other volunteers do when they’re here!!), and then in the afternoon our ‘work’ might be bathing the elephants (one of the most amazing experiences I've ever done), then chopping up sugar cane (a 10 minute job at most), and then feeding the elephants (helping them devour a basket of fruit and sugar cane). Don’t get me wrong -this is a bloody marvellous experience, and one that I know some people would hand over their left leg to do. My issue is with them calling it ‘volunteering’. ‘Getting-rich-westerners-to-part-with-their-money-in-exchange-for-a-feeling-of-good-karma’ is probably closer to the truth.

The very lovely Arun-Ria on her way back from the water hole after a nice bath!

That said, this whole amazing enterprise is only viable because these rich westerners (I’m including ourselves in that) handing over their money, and because I genuinely see the good that this organisation is doing, and for that reason regardless of how valuable the actual work you do whilst here it, I do think it’s a worthwhile project to ‘volunteer’ with. I am also aware that volunteering must in no way take the place of local jobs, so I do understand that a balance must be met that gives volunteers work to keep them busy, whilst not stepping on anyone else’s toes. The Cambodian Sanctuary employs about 50 local people to work on the land, look after the animals, protect the forest (more on this later), manage the garden and nursery, and just keep the site running, which is actually wonderful to see. We have offered to do one or two things around the sanctuary to help out where we thought it might be helpful, but have been told in a friendly way that they’d prefer we didn’t as there are local people employed to do that, which of course we respected.


So, my verdict? This is a wonderful place which I would totally recommend to anyone with a sympathetic inclination...Just please don’t go home showing off how great you are that you’ve rescued elephants. And neither will I. 

7 comments:

  1. hi Emma,
    I enjoyed your post! We as a family are going to 'volunteer' next year and are considering the Cambodian sanctuary but also considering the one in Chiang Mai. I take on your comments about voluntourism and it sounds like this place serves a good balance between actually help and giving us the western folk a warm fuzzy. It is actually perfect as we are bringing our 2 girls with us (12 and 13 yrs old). A question...did you meet anyone that volunteered in Chiang Mai? We are trying to gauge which place might be better suited for our girls. I hope you don't mind me asking. - Gavin (Melbourne, Australia)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. Hi Gavin, I'm so sorry for the delay responding-I don't seem to get notifications about comments, so this only just popped onto my radar. Great news that you're heading to do some volunteering and what a wonderful experience for the kids! As it happens we actually spent a week at the ENP Journey to Freedom project near Chang Mai which includes a night at the Elephant Nature Park, so we've actually experienced 3 of their projects. In terms of the CWS vs JTF-we absolutely loved them both and think either would be well-suited to girls their age. In terms of preferences for each, I would say the JTF near Chang Mai just had the edge as you also do English teaching in the local community and there are kids of all ages there, so I think that would be a wonderful opportunity for your girls to really have a valuable experience and meet some local kids. I also think it was slightly better organised.

      I personally definitely wouldn't recommend you spend a week at the large ENP park in Chang Mai which is the popular, over-subscribed one as it felt much more like a zoo and there were many many volunteers so it felt far less personal. Also, If you do the Chang Mai Journey To Freedom, you still get to go there for 24 hours. Perhaps decide which country you'd rather go to first and let that make the decision for you!

      If you want to read my posts about the Journey to Freedom have a look here-

      http://adoseofsalts.blogspot.co.uk/2015/10/the-journey-to-freedom-enp.html and here http://adoseofsalts.blogspot.co.uk/2015/10/meet-elephants.html

      I hope that helps, and I hope you have a wonderful experience with your girls. Emma

      Delete
  2. Hi Emma,
    My high school daughter is considering a trip to this park next year after her graduation - in Cambodia for 1-2 weeks. Can you tell me how many other volunteers there were with you at the time? Age range? She wants to go by herself to better meet and connect with others, but I'd like to get a sense for how likely it is she'll meet other young people from around the world (vs just a few families). Also, how were the accomodations?

    Thanks in advance!
    Shelley

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Shelley, To be honest, at the time we went, there were only 5 volunteers in total the first week we were there, and 4 in total the following week so it was actually very quiet. I know that they have busier and quieter times of year though so it might be busier earlier on in the summer. It might be worth her trying to contact them to see if they can give her any idea of how many others are considering going for the time she's looking at. That said we only booked ourselves in a couple of weeks before, so they may not be able to tell you I'm afraid. It really was a great experience though, so I would definitely recommend it.

      The accommodation is fairly basic but we thought it was great for volunteering facilities, although we had been travelling a long time so it depends what you're used to. We had our own secure little hut with comfortable bed, mozzie nets and our own balcony in a beautiful setting. The food was amazing (all vegetarian) and staff very friendly. The shower block was very basic - If I remember I think it had proper showers, but they were cold, which is pretty standard for that part of the world (and to be honest quite welcome).

      I hope that helps anyway. Let me know if you need any more advance and good luck to your daughter.

      Emma

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. in this current digital world, students do no longer want to go physically to writing specialists one by one and meet them to spend whole day. Now, they just need to discover a right writing experts just like the actuarial exam dot com.
    Volunteer Sri Lanka

    ReplyDelete